Three Popes

We’ve seen three popes in the four weeks since my last blog.
On the 21st April Pope Francis surrendered his earthly role as Bishop of Rome and Supreme Pontiff of the Universal Church. The Argentinian priest by the name of Jorge Mario Bergoglio, held a papacy marked by a commitment to humility and justice.

He openly condemned Russia’s illegal invasion of Ukraine and consistently advocated for the rights and well-being of migrants and refugees.

When asked by a reporter about Gay Priests in the Vatican, he famously replied “Who am I to Judge”, a stance that signalled a shift towards a more inclusive and merciful Church.

From his first day as Pontiff, Pope Francis opted to live in the Vatican guest house rather than occupy the Papal Palace and chose to wear a basic cassock and pair of black leather shoes from his neighbourhood Argentine cobbler, over the traditional bejewelled robes and ruby red slippers of his predecessors.

He kissed the feet of prisoners and politicians alike, and in a final act of political protest, he requested, by written will and testament, that his Pope-mobile be converted into a mobile hospital for the people of Gaza.

Some say he needlessly conflated politics with his role as Pontiff. I say he knew exactly what his role was, to follow the words of Christ and to love the prisoner, the widow, the orphan, the refugee, “the least of these brothers and sisters of mine” (Matt 25:40).

I tuned in, alongside millions around the world, on Thursday night (8th May), after white smoke emerged from the Sistine chapel’s chimney. I noticed the shock of those gathered in St Peter’s Square as they announced the first ever North American Pope, an unexpected appointee. President Trump and Vice President Vance were quick to congratulate the Chicago born Pontiff and celebrate his appointment, as the world’s reporters rushed to reveal all they could on the man we knew little about.
Robert Francis Prevost was born in Chicago, 1955 to working class parents with a mixture of French, Italian and Spanish lineage. After joining the priesthood, he spent much of his career serving the people of Peru before being brought in recent years to perform as a close aide to Pope Francis in Rome.
With President Trump’s ‘America First’ agenda dominating the international news cycle, the world paused to consider if Pope Leo – the US national, would be a supporter of the current administration and its aggressive foreign policy.

A tweet was quickly uncovered, posted in February this year by Archbishop Prevost, rebuking the Vice President’s theological rational for hostile statements towards immigrants and refugees. Other reposts from Prevost’s X account have suggested the new Pope supports protecting immigrants, reducing gun violence and combating climate change.

The conservative US voting block referred to as MAGA (Make America Great Again) have spoken out in reaction to this discovery, calling Pope Leo another “Woke Marxist Pope.”

In the two weeks that separated Francis and Leo’s papacy, another man temporarily held office. On the 3rd May Pope Trump posted an AI generated image of himself in the Holy Father’s garbs, sat on the throne of St Peter.

It would be unfair to compare the men, since their roles are very different, the Pope’s responsibility is to lead the Roman Catholic Church whilst the President’s is to advance the interests of the United States. But since Trump posted the image himself, it should permit us to imagine how his papacy might differ. Would Pope Trump stand up for the poor, the migrant, the victims of war, the marginalised, those perceived as weak? Would he opt for the guest house or put himself in the Papal palace?  Would he choose a humble attire or decorate himself in jewellery? Is there room for a golden escalator in the Sistine chapel?

With the US President recently celebrating his first 100 days in office, he has boasted of many achievements, the number of people deported being one of his loudest brags.

As thousands across the Global South suffer the death of USAID funding (with Boston University estimating nearly 90,000 child deaths so far) longstanding allies subjected to punishing trade tariffs are being forced to reconsider their reliance on, and relationship with, the ‘leader of the free world’.

With deportations up and illegal entries down, many see Trump as victorious in his fight against violent criminals who make their home in the US. It’s possible that those involved in organised immigration crime and human trafficking are finding the US a more hostile environment in which to operate. I would be the first to celebrate any reduction in modern slavery, however the likelihood is that an increasingly intimidating immigration policy also works in the favour of traffickers, further deterring victims from coming forward and seeking help from the authorities.

Some Christians believe passionately that God moved the bullet to spare the man and insist that Donald Trump is not only a committed Christian but the Lord’s choice for President. Perhaps he did survive as an act of divine intervention, but does that make him an agent of the Almighty? Should his actions in office be interpreted as the will of God? Does the maker of heaven and earth wish for the US President to diminish the realities of climate change, make enemies of his closest trading partners and see the gap between rich and poor grow ever wider?

I wonder what Popes Francis and Leo would think?