Coffee Shop Conspiracies.

I was working in our coffee shop a few weeks back on a particularly hot summer’s afternoon, when a lady walked in to buy a flat white and commented on the weather:

“Wow, today really is hot – but it’s got nothing to do with climate change, I’ll tell ya, that’s a load of made-up rubbish.”

An odd interjection to make to a routine coffee order I thought. I could see that this customer wanted to start a conversation and I was game to hear more.

“Oh really, you don’t believe that climate change is real?”
I asked, giving her permission to evangelise the shop with her beliefs on the matter. (All views are welcome at Blue Bear).

“No of course not. It’s a complete hoax made up by the government to control us all.”

“Oh interesting,” I responded. “which government?”

“….All of them.” She replied, before going on to broadcast further theories on the mendacious meddling of the deep state.

The problem with these conspiracies was how poorly they fit together—like a jigsaw puzzle with mismatched pieces. Most, if not all were mutually incompatible, other than their consistent view of the authorities as fundamentally deceptive.

The belief that climate change was a hoax, for example, clashed with her later reference to the government spraying chemicals in the sky from airplanes to weaken the effects of the sun.

The belief that Covid 19 was deployed by governments to lock people down, met uncomfortably with it’s use as a bioweapon to thin out the global population.

And then there was Microsoft founder Bill Gates, who, in our customer’s eyes, was some sort of corrupt global villain, despite being one of the world’s most generous philanthropists.

President Trump, however, was an agent of the Almighty sent to save the western world, despite his decision to scrap all international development spending (USAID), whilst doubling his personal fortune.

Most conspiracy theories often grow from a seed of truth, and before leaving with her (now cold) flat white, she finally said something that I happened to agree with. At least in part.

“It’s like in Rotherham, you see, the government tried to cover it up for years, but the truth is finally out. Children were being sexually abused by Pakistani grooming gangs and nothing was being done about it.”

And on that one, she was right.

Baroness Casey‘s recent national audit into group-based child sexual exploitation identified a trend which did involve men of Pakistani and South Asian origin operating in groups to traffic and sexually exploit teenage girls. The report also found that a reluctance by authorities to address ethnicity concerns contributed to failures in the investigations.

It is upon these foundations of institutional failure that people’s mistrust in the state is justified and political parties which stoke division and disunity grow in popularity.

There is also a danger that other forms of CSE (Child Sexual Exploitation) may go unnoticed. Lynn Perry, chief executive of Barnardo’s Children’s Charity, said in response to Baroness Casey’s audit:

“It’s also important to remember that abuse takes many forms, and in addition to tackling group-based sexual exploitation, action must be taken to protect children from abuse by family members, within institutions, and to address the increase in abusive behaviour by other children. With one in 10 children in England and Wales thought to experience sexual abuse before they turn 16.”

A few days later, an old colleague from my police days stopped by with his family for coffee and donuts. He now works in a specialised unit investigating online child sexual exploitation (OSEC). “It’s gone through the roof since covid,” he told me. A statement reinforced by a study released in January by the Internet Watch Foundation that reported an 830% increase in the sharing of online child sexual abuse imagery over the past ten years, with 2024 being the worst year yet.

What frustrates me most about the conspiracist community is the common use of “child sex trafficking” as a political device. An unquestionable evil misrepresented and weaponised against a bizarre list of famous faces from politics, business and Hollywood. Such narratives suggest that this crime type is perpetrated exclusively by cabals of wealthy elites, rather than confronting the reality that child sexual abuse is happening at unprecedented levels online, in our communities, families and friendship groups.

The tragedy is that beneath all the conspiracy theories and political point-scoring, there’s a genuine crisis that demands our attention. When institutional failures create fertile ground for mistrust, it becomes harder to focus on the real work of protecting children. The conspiracy theories distract from the unglamorous but vital task of properly funding child protection services, training professionals to spot the signs of abuse, and creating systems that put children’s safety before political convenience.

Perhaps the only area where my coffee shop customer and I found common ground – beyond the grand conspiracies and political villains, was the simple truth that children deserve better protection.

Sometimes the most important conversations happen not when we’re disputing the points which divide us, but focussed on fixing what we both know to be broken—together.