Dog Whistle

I miss my Nan dearly. She was the most wonderfully generous woman who possessed a staggering capacity to love. She brought a warmth and a security to my life that has not been replaced since her passing a few years back. My Nan, however, occasionally made comments that could only be described as racist, or, at the very least, prejudice. Repeating beliefs, inherited from her Father, which accused migration from Muslim countries bringing downfall to the United Kingdom. Remarks made casually and occasionally. Less and less as she grew older and said views appeared increasingly outdated. Views that were completely inconsistent with a woman who would open her door to anyone, and welcomed in my friends, regardless of their race, gender, sexuality or ethnicity, as if they were family.

A politician named Enoch Powel gave a speech in parliament in 1968 titled the Rivers of Blood, in which he warned of the grave consequences of unintegrated migration in the UK. The speech heralded a new wave of hate crime that dogged the 1970’s and later merged with the football hooliganism of the 80’s to display the very worst parts of our culture. Powel would have likely shuddered at the thought of their being such an ethnically diverse array of politicians today, which have included in recent years a Hindu Prime minister and non-white Chancellor of the Exchequer, Home Secretary and London Mayor. Times change.

I warned before the recent general election of the rising far right political movement, as many people in this country looked for a party that prioritised their interests above those who have entered by unofficial or “illegal” means. People are fed up. They have lived through a global financial crash on a scale not before seen (2009), a global health pandemic that cost the country billions (2019), and the impact of Putin’s invasion of Ukraine (2022) resulting in a massive rise in living costs. Migration has risen significantly in recent years, by official and unofficial means, and that does out a strain on the public purse. Communities have begun to look different to how they once appeared and some of this can be hard to absorb or accept. Such are the circumstances in which we find ourselves.

This is by no means a uniquely British problem, with similar economic and social issues encountered by governments across Europe. Most of our nearest neighbours have seen a rise in populist nationalist movements as a consequence and the growth of the far right is evident in the US Republican Party and Netanyahu’s Israeli coalition government. Certain politicians claim to be saying, with increasing boldness, what we the people are no longer allowed to. Or so they claim.

There is a term for this unique style of communication, it’s called a Dog Whistle. To borrow a Wikipedia definition, the dog whistle means:

“the use of coded or suggestive language in political messaging to garner support from a particular group without provoking opposition. The concept is named after ultrasonic dog whistles, which are audible to dogs but not humans.”

Most of the statements however are far less subtle than the term suggests.

Convicted criminal and far right activist Stephen Christopher Yaxley-Lennon, also known as Tommy Robinson, has once again become a popular voice for the far right after Elon Musk allowed him back onto X (formerly Twitter). Robinson has been busy organising marches to stand up for the ‘working people of Britian’. After the recent Southport tragedy, Robinson tweeted:

“When British people are ignored and labelled ‘far-right’ … something has to happen.”

A curious statement that suggests that these scenes of wanton destruction and violence are in response to people being wrongfully labelled “far right” ? How many shops must I then rob Tommy to prove I’m not a thief? A new way of justifying nationalistic thuggery if ever I’ve heard one.

Nigel Farage, MP and leader of the Reform UK Party chose to avoid Parliament on Monday when the riots were being discussed, opting instead to use his social media platform to further stoke division by claiming that:

“Ever since the soft policing of the Black Lives Matter protests, the impression of two-tier policing has become widespread”. 

Farage used his Dog Whistle to suggest that our Police Service is unduly lenient to people of colour and overly robust in responding to protests carried out by white Britons, pursuant to his “anti-woke” agenda.

*(I attended the BLM protests in 2020 as a bodyguard for an LBC radio presenter and after narrowly missing a charge of the police horses I can confirm that these were not soft public order policing techniques!)

Farage has also been guilty of offloading untested conspiracy theories in response to the Southport tragedy, claiming that “some reports believe the man (Southport attacker) was known to the security services”, and questioned “whether the truth was being withheld from us.”

The man, in this case, was a 17-year-old Christian boy born in Cardiff to Rwandan parents, contrary to online posts claiming he was a Muslim asylum seeker who arrived in the country by a small boat.

Alleged human trafficker and unapologetic misogynist Andrew Tate was also quick to start spreading disinformation, claiming the attacker was an “illegal migrant” and told people to “wake up”. Joining in with this harmony of falsehood, tech billionaire and culture warrior Elon Musk has been actively stoking the flames with statements that “civil war in the UK is unavoidable.”

We need to be aware of those blowing their Dog Whistles with languid statements that place the blame for all of the country’s complex economic and social problems at the foot of the Migrant or the Muslim. Despite the utter refusal by populist right wing leaders to accept the term racist, that is exactly what this is. This time I’ll borrow from the Oxford Dictionary of Terms:

“Racism: Prejudice, discrimination, or antagonism by an individual, community, or institution against a person or people on the basis of their membership of a particular racial or ethnic group, typically one that is a minority or marginalized.”

Let us not return to a time when racial hatred was commonplace and people from any marginalised group felt unsafe in this country. Multiculturalism has not failed, it just needs work.

I have written before of the complexity of immigration and I am a firm believer in the value of secure borders and the rule of law. Insecure migration does indeed allow for the infiltration of organised crime and human trafficking. Any suggestion otherwise would be foolish. Climate change, conflict, religious persecution and global inequality are huge drivers of mass migration, accelerated by the growth in internet connectivity across the global south and access to social media. This is a global issue that requires a global response. I do not believe that an isolationist, protectionist, or nationalist response will effectively tackle this multi-dimensional and uniquely international challenge. Or put far more succinctly:

“Alone we can do so little, together we can do so much.”
Helen Keller.

Last night the streets were flooded with anti racism protestors carrying banners of peace and placards of love, chanting “refugees are welcome here.”

I would like to hope that some of those peace seeking protestors come from Reform voting households, who’s views, perhaps like my Nan, don’t prohibit them from displaying compassion. People who may be persuaded that we are best approaching our differences when walking side by side.