The Perills of Indifference

Last year I attended a number of speaking events across the country, sharing the story of Blue Bear Coffee, the work of our foundation, information about human trafficking and warning all present to the “perils of indifference.” The term comes from a famous speech given in 1999 by Nobel Laureate and Holocaust survivor, Professor Elie Wiesel. President Bill Clinton had invited a number of renowned speakers to the White House to address a gathered crowd of esteemed guests at the dawn of the new millennium. Professor Weisel chose this hopeful moment to warn of the perils of indifference and the seductive allure of apathy.

“Can one possibly view indifference as a virtue? Is it necessary at times to practice it simply to keep one’s sanity, live normally, enjoy a fine meal and a glass of wine, as the world around us experiences harrowing upheavals? …Indifference is not a beginning, it is an end, indifference is always the friend of the enemy, for it benefits the aggressor — never his victim, whose pain is magnified when he or she feels forgotten.”

At the turn of this New Year, it seems fitting to remember Elie’s warning. War marches on in the Ukraine, conflict rages in Sudan and the Congo, and a complete absence of peace exists in the middle east. Israel’s coalition government continues its campaign of self-defence, with over 40,000 Palestinians dead (70% women and children) and 157 UN Member States calling for a ceasefire – including the United Kingdom.

Institutions such as the ICC (International Criminal Court), NATO and the United Nations are under threat. For the first time since the end of the second world, the European Convention of Human Rights (ECHR) has been openly criticised by some of our leaders who have begun to view its statutes as inconvenient, obstructive and open for interpretation.

The subject of immigration continues to dominate the political landscape, few politicians however have been able to make the connection between international conflict and the waves of small boats landing on British shores. If we are to lament the illegal crossings, we would benefit by investing in peace building missions, diplomacy, and upholding international institutions.

‘What has this got to do with coffee or human trafficking!?’  I hear you say! Well, it might be a stretch to link it to coffee, possible but a stretch, it does however have everything to do with human trafficking. Behind climate change, conflict is the greatest driver of human trafficking and modern slavery, as displaced people flee their homes and are made increasingly vulnerable to exploitation.

I am occasionally criticised for commenting on social issues that, for some, exist outside the umbrella of modern slavery. This critique however is ignorant to the fact that suffering does not exist in silos. Poverty, homelessness, domestic violence, sexual exploitation … there is a thread that connects them all. You cannot address one whilst ignoring the others, or put rather more eloquently:

“Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.” Martin Luther King Jnr, 1963.

‘But what can we do?’

It is true that there are far too many problems for any one person to solve or even care about. We certainly can’t do everything, but everyone can do something. For some, buying coffee from a Social Enterprise such as our own might be a good starting point, or helping fundraise for our Foundation. Others might choose to get involved in supporting international organisations or look locally to their nearest community projects. I am convinced that individual responses to injustice can create a tidal wave of change.

Thousands of mourners gathered on Thursday (9th) at Washington National Cathedral to memorialise the recently deceased former US President Jimmy Carter, who died on 29th December 2024 aged 100 years old. President Carter was uniquely revered by leaders on both sides of the political spectrum and became as well known for his activities since leaving office than those for which he undertook as commander and chief (1977-1981). He cared greatly about racial equality, human rights and peace in the middle east, and spent much of his post presidential life working with developmental organisations and on peace building missions.

In President Biden’s eulogy, he described Carter as,

“a white Southern Baptist who led on civil rights. A decorated Navy veteran who brokered peace. A brilliant nuclear engineer who led on nuclear non-proliferation. A hard-working farmer who championed conservation and clean energy.”

There was once a trend amongst young Christians who wore wrist bands with the letters, WWJD, which stood for the words ‘What Would Jesus Do?’ I wonder, if times were different and the recently deceased US statesman was in charge of today’s White House, What Would Jimmy Do?

Jimmy Carter was a leader who, above all else, understood the importance of peace, having grown up during the second world war, and famously told his Oslo audience in 2002, upon receiving the Nobel Peace Prize:

“War may sometimes be a necessary evil. But no matter how necessary, it is always an evil, never a good. We will not learn to live together in peace by killing each other’s children.”

I hope that more leaders this year will heed the words of Professor Elie Weisel, Dr Martin Luther King and President Jimmy Carter. And I for one intend to keep repeating them.

If you would like to hear more about Blue Bear Coffee, human trafficking or ways of resisting indifference, why not book us to speak at your event in 2025?

Find out more by emailing info@bluebearcoffee.com